(I also have that song, and I'm listening to it right now. I've toyed with Jeb/Reilly songfic for it in the past, which is why I laughed so hard seeing it here.)
I was thinking for super incest bonus points of squick, it's Max leaving Jeb for Ari. And Iggy should totally be Jeb's rebound boyfriend, because hey, why not.
The class a year ahead of me used that as their 8th grade graduation song. We hold our graduations in a church. I laughed so hard, as did the few who got it.